Originally Posted by
Champlain Islander
All the modern xbows I have seen shoot are pretty deadly at 50 plus yards. They shoot flat and fast which must still have more than enough kinetic energy to kill at that distance. If they didn't have the range they would be falling off the table at longer yardages and from what I have seen they are just the opposite. I don't own one and hopefully never will but I have shot them and if you can point and aim a gun it is the same. Being accurate with a bow requires lots more skill because of form, equipment matching and overall experience. Certainly the ease of killing something is much harder with a bow because you have to move to draw and there is only a certain amount of time you can hold at full draw. A xbow is always ready and all you have to do is pull the trigger. Like everything there are limits placed on what is allowed. Many places don't allow semi automatics for instance. Some places don't allow rifles. Placing a limit on bows that have to be drawn to shoot without a hold would eliminate the xbows and draw locks that are becomming more popular. I still maintain that if all the states allowed xbows to be used with a medical waiver then it would make more sence. To me a crossbow is just a line in the sand. Places have to determine how far they will allow it to go before the original intent of the season and method is lost.
I don't doubt that the xbow is easier to shoot. That doesn't really matter to me. Why didnt we put a limit on compound bows at 50% let off ? Most are now at 80 % and some more. It's getting easier. Why did P&Y chnage the rules for let off? We have trail cams to make scouting easier. Mechanical broadheads to make tuning easier. Why go to inline muzzleloaders ? Nothing is getting harder for anyone
The thing is times are changing if you like it or not. Deer numbers keep going up and hunter numbers keep going down. Something needs to be done to keep hunters in the sport. Seasons are getting longer and longer. It's already shown that the xbow isn't hurting anyone or anything. You can say what ever you like but it's just the fact. The population is not suffering and the seasons are not getting shorter.