RE: 357 mag w/ 170 Gold dots for deer?
If you limit your shots to close range it should be sufficent. I personally think a 41 mag as a min for deer.Of course shot placement is a must.You would be much better off investing in a 41mag,44mag 45Colt,454 Casull or a Ruger 480.We owe it to the animal to make the most humane kills as possible.
Ruger Redhawk