I guess that would be up to someone that shoots a 28" draw, wouldn' t it.

What' s acceptable to you might be overkill for me. What' s acceptable for me might give you a heart attack. You ever used the graphing trajectory calculator on Jacksons site? Take a peek at the difference between a 250 fps arrow and a 300 fps arrow sometime. You might be suprized at how little that extra speed does to flatten short yardage trajectory.