I can't comment on the Judge, never shot one, but years ago, bought the wife a five shot Taurus .38 snubby, so-so craftsmanship, sloppy cylinder, cylinder to barrel gap too wide and yet it shots well, has been 100% reliable and wonder of wonders doesn't spit lead---for some reason, she loves it. I have always had Smith's and only Smith's, but lately a single six and a Redhawk have joined my collection and I'm more than impressed--very well made and reliable guns. My advice would be to get something that's downsized a little [ concealeable ], and chambered in 45 Long Colt or .44 Special--easy recoil and still packs a wallop, and would you believe it, Smith and Ruger both make such a gun!!--------------John