My vote goes for the Marlin 60. Just bought one off the consignment rack at work about a month ago. I was there when the guy brought it in and he said he might have shot at the most 50 rounds through it. I have since then put over 1000 rounds through it and its the funnest gun i have ever shot. Only paid $100 for it and it was spotless. no scratches or anything. Its accurate enough that i started doing trick shooting with it. shooting coins and charcoal brickettes out of the air and even shot 5 or 6 playing cards in half on edge with it before i even emptied the 14round tube mag from about 15 yards away. all of this was done with open sights and i plan on leaving it that way. Model 60s are cheaper than a 10/22 most of the time and you dont have to blister your fingers when shooting for a long time at the range reloading magazines.