Originally Posted by
Pete D.
Y'know....not everyone is talking about the same thing here.
There's "will it kill a grizzly?" and there's "will it stop a grizzly?"
Not nearly the same thing.
You'd have to be extraordinarily lucky to stop an agitated/angry/hungry grizzly with ANY handgun. The fellow in AK who had the encounter with the Griz whilst walking his dog......yeah, he killed it but he didn't stop it, though he sure came close:
"Rolled him at 5 feet and he
skidded to a stop 10 feet BEYOND where I was
Shooting from...."
"Stop it" means that the animal does not get to you. He was lucky to survive and he knows it. His sidestep probably saved him from real hurt (he ended up on his butt). Had the animal only run him over (as opposed to mauling), he'd have been in bad shape.
Pete
There is probably nothing on this earth, short of .416 Rigby or .500 Nitro mag (or RPG or M203 grenade launcher) that will "Stop" a charging grizzly. That hot 454 casull round did a fantastic job killing that Grizzly, I don't think you could have asked a handgun to do any better. Also, what are the chances that guy would have taken a large caliber rifle with him to walk his dog?