Doug says: "Sure a significantly higher kill will reduce the herd even more."
Actually thats not true.
ANY higher will reduce the herd further when stabilization or reduction is already occurring. You yourself even stated previously when discussing pa game lands management vs. stateforest how even small increases in harvest (in that case with dmap) would have real effect on deer density when they are low to begin with. Hope we arent gonna waffle on that now?

..........
He he, yeah, i caught that NY. But then not much i read here these days surprises me.
Maybe he knows some of these guys from Pa use alot of out of state guides & outfitters for their deer hunting?