Just curious about a couple of things. Where are you located and is what is the average deer populaton in the area? How big is the tract of land you are trying to use? Hard to believe that in a year you are still having that kind of problem, I think the dog pen is a big part of the problem. Stick to the pure corn, the peanut butter will draw the rest of the unwanted critters like duezee said. Your post is confusing, in the first part you state "I have tracked the woods and found trails, scrapes, etc" and then further down you say "No tracks or anything!", can't be both.