Where does PJ mention that he got this Capture "cheap"? I don't see that. Anyway, my Capture that I just got in August has been working the way Cuddeback cams are rumored to work, beautifully! I don't know why you think the case isn't durable? As far as the batteries go, I've no issues with them coming loose or any loss of connection. They're in nice and snug. Also, no issues with the gasket at all. You had to have pulled it out somehow, and now it doesn't want to go back properly? Otherwise, I go with most everything else you've said.
The only legit gripe I have is the BOGUS security system, or lack there of! You might as well just bungee 2 one hundred dollar bills to the friggen tree and walk away!! What a joke!!!! Also, this stupid strap is in the middle of the cam, so it's much more prone to moving. It should be secured top and bottom.
They also need to make EVERY CUDDEBACK with that long screw that secures it from the inside like the Excite cam has. It too, is a hassel, but at least the cam is truely "secured" to the tree. At least they have to break the cam before they can steal it.
I think for the money, the Cuddeback Capture is at or very near the top. I'll be getting another. Oh, don't forget they also have great battery life!