bluebird,YOU WON.rule is is 1 INCH.if point is not 1 inch ,its not legal.question is on this buck with broken off point that was most likely 8 inchs long with broken area 1 inch or close left on beam,would a wco take exception to this ADULT buck.

i would not think so.if that area was smooth on beam with nothing sticking up on that ADULT buck,yes i would expect to be arrested .
this is why so many are getting the kids tags,they dont have to worry about this if it happens,they just shoot.
i saw crew shooting at adult buck that had only 2 points on side and no brow tines. i saw this buck on sunday before opening of season.i even told them that this buck was in my area and to be on look out for him.its horns were very big about 18 inch spread.what did adults in crew do?they shot at him running accross pipeline in front of me going to my truck.
i was so mad i started yelling at them.they said they were going to turn me in for yelling at them while hunting.
well they did not because i would have told wco that they are using the kids tags.
i bet they dont come back next year to that spot.

sorry i got off topic.