I have the plano one in your second link. I like it. Holds my bow with the quiver still on it and extra arrows in the lid. Its foam padded also. I got mine at a local sporting goods store on sale for $20. If your just looking for one to put your bow in at home, or while your travleing in your truck, this one works for me. But I wouldnt use it to put it on a plane.... I would want something hard sided for flying.