i agree and kinda disagree with this. i seen a video on you tube the other day a guy shot a buck while it was fighting with another one i think that was very inhumane. also i would never kill a deer while it was breeding once again would you like to be shot when you getting ur love on i think not. but all in all killing young bucks if you kill all the young ones how you every gonna kill bigger ones. in my opion i would kill a 6-8-10-12-14-16 and so one but if i see a button or a spike or even a little 4 pointer i will let them go deer gain. alot on there antlers every year so why not wait till next year to kill the little ones it doesnt hurt anything. besides raising the bar makes you become a better and better hunter. and tv has ruined hunting. and America is the only country where they take your rights and then you can have them back for a price example... hunting, driving, etc etc all in all i would never discourage a young hunter you want to encourage them explain to them what they did wrong and help them become better God knows we all did the same things they do.