sconnyhunter,
We sit on opposites sides of the argument ye or nay for the .223. Some of what you say, I agree with totally... and some, well, LOL!... I don't.
Anyway, I just wanted to say I appreciate your civility in the manner in which you shared your opinion.
On an after-thought, you brought a good point about the buck fever issue we all go through during the heat of the moment and if a youngster can handle it... and I have to say that's a good answer for against.
Still I could argue it could happen with any caliber... and again could argue that 100% of the deer broadside shot in the heart/lung area will be dead... but I won't. LOL!
Your opinions are noted and with good cause. Good job.
iSnipe