I also hunt NY.I have a pair of 1200 gram Thinsulate with the outside being mostly GoreTex.As has already been mentioned,buy a pair at least 1 size bigger so you can move your toes.
I'll never buy another pair of Rocky boots.Last year the tread started to come off in chunks and they were only 3 years old.I've read that other guys have had the same problem with there Rocky boots.Some of there's were newer than mine and 2 guys were wearing new boots.