It never happened to me but my dad had a 4, 6 and 8 pointer taken. At the end of the 4-point's blood trail was a gut pile and tire tracks in the field. The 6-point was shot while it was down and the guy claimed that he fired the finishing shot. The 8-point was shot after my dad hit it fataly but he gave it to the guy anyway because he fired the last shot. A few other fellows in our old hunting club had similar experiences.

Scott Meier
White Oak Lodge