I haven’t tried the Beretta Xtrema but it’s my next shotgun... I have the Beretta model 301 semi-auto and have never had any problems with it... I’ve hunted all types of birds from big Canadas to Sharp-Tailed Grouse and the gun has never failed me... The gun handles well under all weather conditions and it can get pretty cold and ugly up here... I have to admit I should keep it cleaner then I do but it has never been a problem... My brother has a newer Beretta Semi-auto (not the extrema) and also has had no problems with it either...I’ve hunted years with my Beretta and would highly recommend it... Good luck in your purchase and I don’t think you’ll regret it.