If I had the Land and resources he had I would do exactly as he is doing! Should he shoot younger bucks when theres big 6+ year olds running around? That is a no brainer and its obvious these guys at the top of our sport got there by not making stupid decisions.
So pretty much what youre saying is if theres a field full of does and young bucks and even though this property is 3000 acres and holds many mature bucks just go ahead and shoot the 2 year old six pointer. Thats a good one, remind me not to hire you to manage my property!!