Well, I have used extensive attractants over the last two years, from Cocain Mix, to Ruttin Apples, Black Magic Insta-Lik, Block Topper, Buck Grub, Shake n Take,C'Mere Deer liquid and have used these in conjunction with corn,apples and mineral/salt licks and have had very little success. So why do I buy them to this day?? Because of posts such as these, what seems to be very good homework on your part, minus a couple of small holes and the fact that I am hoping that because of all the ag feilds I have around me in plays into it (Corn,beans,alfalfa). I have several pics of deer walking within 5 yards of some of this stuff and keep on walking, but they are taking down the alflafa now and soon enough the beans and corn so we will see how it goes.
Good job and good post!