You' re kidding? I' ve got a Blueridge 3-D deer target I got two years ago and it is great! My buddies and I have shot it with carbons and aluminums over and over and over! I' ve never had an arrow go more than 3-4 inches in it. The foam is so tuff it' s almost impossible to get the arrows out without a rubber arrow puller. Sorry to hear of your bad luck but mine is great!