My bad. You are right. I was counting the pictures wrong. So you are saying numbers 1, 2 and 3 are NOT the same as numbers 4 and 5. You are with the majority.
I think you may be right if the majority rules Me, I still think he is the same buck, just better this year. He won't reach his potential though if he gets under my stand and my arrow finds him I can't take the chance that someone else or worse, a car, will get him.