If you can't decide, I'd be happy to come along and take him. Last year I had a buck I named 'Off-limits' He was a year old deer that was a 9 point. G2's both split and the one side had 3 brows and the other none. Tight little rack that I thought would grow into a giant.

I passed him on November 13th. That was the last I saw of him. My guess is someone count 4 points on one side and now he is history. He was a regular on my TC last year.

Like you said, unless you can strictly manage, take him out.