DANG!!!!!! Tough question..I'm actually 50-50 between spinning and baitcaster..but I voted baitcaster..
This morning ..
I started 30 minutes Horny Toad Baitcaster.
Next hour was spinning with spinner bait..my only fish of the day..
I finished off bummping a worm with baitcaster..
I also chucked a deep diver with my spinning rod..
50-50..with a slight bent to baitcaster..If I had my rathers..I'd go with spinning..better tackle for less money..IMHO {-: