I don't know about the others but I've used both the Wildlife research and the dead down wind. Here in Florida we worry about bugs in the house so the kitchen garbage can is kept in the garage. On more than one occasion "liquid garbage" has leaked from the bag into the can and went unnoticed until the garage started stinking to high heaven. Forget using Fabreeze, either of those products kill the odor immediately. I don't think what brand you use as long as you use something, we hunt in hot weather down here so its used often.