My biggest and probably only complaint is the lack of instruction. It would be great if they gave background information about where they were hunting, the scouting they had done, why the picked a certain location, how long they had to hunt to find the right animal, the time of year, what equipment they were using and why they liked it etc.
Any more, you just see them walk throught the woods, shoot a trophy and get excited. I want to be able to learn from what they do and apply it to what I do; a hunting show what would make me a better hunter. Teach us how to scout better. Show us how to identify the best funnels and stand sites. Give us the why - not just the what.