HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - PGC critic has a bit of crow for supper...
Old 04-21-2009 | 04:07 PM
  #40  
R.S.B.
Typical Buck
 
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 584
Likes: 0
Default RE: PGC critic has a bit of crow for supper...

ORIGINAL: bluebird2

ORIGINAL: WV Gino

Doug

here is more info on this Clinton County land and the deer management
going on there.

Mike sends out surveys to all guys who obtain DMAP coupons. It's amazing
how few deer sightings there are with densities in the 20's



http://huntwestbranch.blogspot.com/2009/01/blog-post.html
RSB claims the habitat in 2G is controlling the herd at less than 10 DPSM in 2G. Can you explain why the poor habitat in Clinton Co. isn't controlling the herd at less than 10 DPSM?


The size of the deer herd in various parts of unit 2G, just like all other areas of the state, varies between much higher then 10 deer per square mile to much lower then 10 deer per square mile depending on the quality of the various habitats surrounding the area in question. There are areas of unit 2G with way more then even 40 deer per square mile but there are also massive areas with way less then 10 deer pre square mile. The area of the link undoubtedly has some of the best and some of the poorer habitat types indicative of the unit.

Obviously if the deer population, within the West Branchlink area,is only at twenty deer per square milewhile hunters are only harvesting 3.37 deer (2.11 antler less and 1.26 antlered) it is the habitat and environmental conditions controlling their deer numbers. If it weren’t the quality of the habitat controlling the deer numbers there should be at least three or four times that many deer living on that tract of land.

Certainly anyone with even a tiny bit of common sense would realize that hunters harvesting only 2.11 per square mile out of a herd of twenty deer per square mile doesn’t equate to an over harvest of the does.

So, since it is so obvious the does, nor the total deer herds, is being over harvested just what do you suppose is preventing the deer from increasing since you don’t believe it could be the poor habitat and environmental conditions keeping the herd from increasing?

R.S. Bodenhorn
R.S.B. is offline  
Reply