I hunt "the same place" a lot, but I don't go in knowing exactly where I'll set up. I let the gobbling birds tell me. I try to get most of the way in unseen/unheard, and then either try to get a shock gobble or wait for them to gobble on their own. Then I figure out where to set up.

But, assuming there is more than one turkey using the woods you hunt, and the spot you hunted/missed is a good spot, such as between a roost and a strut zone, heck yeah, hunt the same spot.