I fully agree that the inlines have gotten completely away from what the original intent of the muzzleloading season was. The ones to blame are the manufacurers namely Tony Knight (the " Pioneer in inline muzzleloading" ), they saw a market for- look and feel like hi-po rifles.
What should be done? I think Colorado is on the right track. Maybe include exposed hammer, and percussion cap. Ban shotgun primers.
Perhaps the exposed hammer is being precieved by the manufacturers of inlines as a new rule coming (Encore, Omega, and other manufacturers are coming out with them.
What do I shoot a Percussion Hawken made by myself in .58. Will shoot roundballs (290gr.) accurately with up to 160gr. 2F at 2000fps. But my hunting load will be 140gr. 1800fps.
I shoot a lot at ranges up to 200yd. If I know the range I would feel very comfortable shooting an elk up to 150yd. Checking ballistic tables this 58 hits as hard a 150yd. as my 54 hit at 75yd.
my opinion for what its worth
David/Mo