The PGC can't even answer 3 simple questions about their plan raised by just an average hunter, so there is no reason to expect that a truly independent audit would conclude the plan was scientifically sound when the PGC doesn't even know how many deer we have or how many have to be harvested to reach their goals.
Wrong again. every question you've asked has been answered logically but you simply dismiss the answers.
We shouldn't be surprised......
You also dismiss theresearch and conclusions of several of the most respected wildlife professionals.
You dismiss the overwhelming evidence that the average PA buck has improved in age structure and as a result antler size and continue to cling to your unsupported high grading theory.
You dismiss the overwhelming evidence of overbrowsing that took place throughout the state before HR and ignore the fact that the regeneration taking place was often restricted to less desirable and less beneficial species.
You dismiss facts presented to you by people with long term experience and knowledge about WMU's that you've seldom if ever set foot in and have the audacity to tell them what things are like where they hunt live and work.
I think RSB hit it dead on when he said you're either afraid of what a truly independent audit will bring or know what it will bring and therefore want to promote an auditor that you can later try to discredit when the inevitable results come.