Im really not sure why anyone would want a larger one
Because of this reason...
I like tobe able to align my peep perfectly around the sight housing when im aiming so I know im consistant. For hunting I use a larger peep for light purposes ...
Exactly. I use a 1/4" peep, and my Hunter Hogg-It's 2 3/8" pin guard makes combines with it to make perfect concentric circles ...
but I still thinksmaller is better...
Isn't that contradicting what you just said? [8D]