The breakdown of the score provides enough evidence for many of the scorers on these forums to pick out discrepancies. IMO

I just look at it this way, it's for fun however what if, let's say JOE gets beat by 2" because of Todd's estimation buck when let's say that Todd's buck really scores 155" and not 160". That's not fair to JOE nor anyone else not anyone else who followed the rules set forth by the contest.

I know Todd didn't enter this contest, he didn't ask to be picked but he was and in all honesty it shouldn't count.

Now, to be fair to those that may have picked Todd, I say randomly draw a name out of all the bucks entered for a replacement. Or not, it's your contest. No real way to call it "fair" since Todd doesn't feel it's respectful to score a bucks antlers.