The only time it bothers me is when I see a deer taken home, then hanging form a tree in their front yard for 2 weeks. It is cases like this where they did not care about the animal and it most likelly went to waste. If you shoot it, take care of it. i also don't care for the guys that buy as many tags as they can and shoot anything that moves, multiple times. These are gun hunters that i am talking about, and i do not have a problem with the gun hunter as I am one of them, jsut the ones that shoot every deer they see. i don't know everyone's situation, and if they are feeding the family, fine, but they all are not doing that.
But for a guy to be happy with their buck, be it a 1 1/5 YO or 4 1/2YO, good for them!