If I were to shoot a glove, the Big Shot is the one I' d use. Sorry, I' ve never used the buffalo glove but I' d really like to feel one before I paid 60$ for one. If I can' t start controlling the finger callous on my ring finger, I might have to return to a glove. The only thing I don' t like about a glove is that I don' t have a distinct feel for my anchor, rather it feels more like a wad of leather against my mouth.