To fill a tag or not to fill a tag, that is the question...???
YOUR question, isn't it?

For me, I would weigh my personal goals and when I pull the trigger (gun or release) I ultimately have to be happy with my choice at that second.
No turning back either way. Either the deer is dead or it's still walking.
I have a 5-year plan (for my goals) and will be patient, however I will deviate from it, if I choose?!
I won't allow myself to cry over spilled milk. Of course you may, but that's your lively hood!

Everyone knows that you may encounter tag soup while holding out for the exact deer your looking for.
Could have, should have, would have??!!?

If I had my own personal property I would manage it for specific goals and stick to them.
However, I may get trigger happy on another piece of property if I choose,
depends on what part of the season and if I want to put meat in the freezer or not?

But your brother can now help with the latter part!