ORIGINAL: buckeye
So you've got a buck pushing 150" that doesn't make "book"?
Matt's buck will easily make P&Y. It was scored wrong.
Then take Kidd642's for another example. Gross' 140's and didn't make book.
Like was mentioned above, P&Y is too deep into their rules to ever change.
I prefer Gross but that's just the way I like it. B&C/P&Y look for perfection. I can see the point in a way but times have changed.