I just got a call from my archery pro shop. With my old arrows I was shooting I got the following

old weight 485grams speed 261fps
new weight 385grams speed 299fps

They paper tuned it for me also and said they didn't have to change a thing. Everything is good to go. There are two things that may have caused poor performance they said. The arrow weight was high and the spine strength was not correct for my bow/arrow combo. Now with those fixed I should be shooting much better.

Thanks for the advise TEmbry. I hope there is something down the road I can help you with.