Troy n Oh
First off I would want a 12 ga that would shoot 3 1/2" shells. The 10ga may pattern better but weighs to much for duck hunting not able to get on them as quick and also just extra weight to carry. Next I would want an auto. Have a few pumps but would go for the auto. So it boils down to a few thats out there then would find one that fits and comes up with ease and right on everytime. All of this pointed me to the Winchester super X. It has been a good gun and used it on ducks, geese, pheasants, grouse, woodcock, huns, sharptail, but mostly for waterfowl.