No question in my mind at all. I'm not hunting his rack, I'm hunting him. I take the shot.
I'm with Greg 100%.
He could have dropped a SIDE and I'd shoot him. When you get a relationship with a deer.....and kill him....you'll realize how special that is. Then maybe you'll change your mind.
For the record....I was prepared to take an 80-90" 6 pointer that I'd watched this summer. It worked out I didn't.....but I'd have been maybe MORE proud of him. Last time I saw him he had ALL his tines busted off.