For me, this would only happen on public land. I say this because, I would be taking a big risk of never seeing him again.

I'm into the horns but, would tell a good story even with a broken tine. I would take the shot unless he was really busted. Ex. if he only had half a rack, I would likely pass.

Also depend on the season for me. Is it late in the season and I don't think other hunters will put him down?.. if so, I would be more likely pass on him till next season.