As I stated, I mean no disrespect. And I feel your advice is solid. I have just found on this forum, and other longgun or hunting forums, that just because you know one type of firearm doesn't make you an expert on another.For example, and I don't believe it was here, but on a hunting forum someone asked for some handgun advice for his wife, a handgun novice. One of the posts suggested a snub-nosed J frame revolver in 357 (not even 38spl). Insane, but that piece of advice may have been given as much credence by others as the other posts. I am simply a "go where the pro's are" kind of guy. That's why for hunting advice, I came to a hunting forum.

FWIW, I think your advice is very solid.