Why do you feel that making a poor shot, whether intentional or not and not recovering the deer until it' s been eaten by other predators entitles you to another tag.
Why would anyone take an intentionally poor shot?
FWIW, I don' t necessarily think that I am entitled to another tag, but it would be worth asking for to me anyway.
Like Rack Attack has said, I have also had the occasion of leaving a lunged deer overnight. Luckily nothing happened to it.
So FFTJ, what would you do, I' m kind of interested in knowing your answers to your questions.