Of the ones you have, I would probably shoot the Naps if I wanted a fixed blade and the Rages are a fine expandable.

I was talking about the number of bladed on broadheads. I use Wasp 4 blades, which have a 1" cutting diameter and I think that they do more damage than the 3 blade Nap that you have, which has 1 1/8" cutting diameter because it has more blades.