Dave:
My Pro-38 has the same problem. I also am tuned to the point that I am not going to make ANY changes to my setup unless disaster strikes. I was shooting broadheads yesterday, and I am very happy with the bow, accuracy and tune.
BUT I have my sight lowered until I only have about 1/4" left of vertical gang adjustment, and my 3 pins are all below center of the pin guard. If I was using a peep, it would be a problem to center the guard. I can get enough adjustment out of my sight, but apparently you can' t, so I can understand why you are upset.
I heard of the offset bracket, and thought about getting one. I was surprised to see this was not on the web site. I am even more surprised to hear that the bracket does not fit.
I don' t understand the rationale for making the sight mount holes so high that most currently available sights will have a problem, then not addressing the problem properly with an available accessory. As good as the bows are, this whole problem just does not make sense.
I personally am not about to change my setup or anchor point to meet the needs of the sight mount holes. My sight looks kind of " goofy" , but consistent broadhead accuracy is what I am after, and I have it so I am not changing.
If you can' t get the place to take your sight back, you could try to sell it on Ebay.
That, or maybe you have another sight on another bow and the switch would work.
I don' t know what else to say. No question, you have reasons to be upset, and Bowtech has reasons to take care of this problem.[:@]