If you're getting fletching contact, then your rest probably needs the timing adjusted, or your nocks aren't rotated properly. Lot of guys enjoy good results with Blazers on that rest and the QAD.

Like rybo was saying, just about any vane will work well off a properly tuned bow. I play with different ones every year on my hunting setup just for fun, and can't say any of them shoot significantly better than the others with a good fixed blade.........as long as it was a reasonable sized vane, I don't mess with the micro vane crap with a broadhead. But they do shoot well on 3-d setups. This year for hunting I tried the AAE Max Hunters, and I like them alot. My Slik Triks out to 50 yds are pounding.