Corey,
What is your rational for believing that given the same shot and neither head passing thru that the Phantom would give you a blood trail and the Steelhead would not?
On game animals the Steelhead will leave a full width cut upon entrance so I am not following your logic? If both heads hit the same place,penetrate to the same place and cut the same tissue on the way in blood trails should and would be basically equal provided both heads were sharpened to the same quality.
That said, do shoot whatever you have 100% confidence in, because when staring down the barrel of a bull Moose I think you' ll agree that your broadhead is the last thing you want to be thinking about
]