RE: Vanes
What kind of glue are you using, Elmers white glue? That is some crap glue you are using, or you might not be using enough.
I noticed you are using titebond. I can only guess that you are not using enough; not letting them set long enough before pulling them out of the jig; or you are glueing them up dirty. Clean both shaft and vane base before glueing.
Ive got arrows that have passed through several animals and never even need to be refletched. Just cleaned up, new broadhead, and good to go.