I have never used DDW, always been Scent Killer for me but just ran out and lookin to try something new. The bottle on the XP is what sold me,lol. I have nothing bad to say about it. I think it works just as good if not better than what i had been using. I get no foul smell from it, and this past weekend had four bucks come up my access trail. the 10pt which i shot was sniffing it and new something but never picked me so i would say that it works pretty good.