DR Kroll refuted Dr Demaris study and pointed out the flaws in Dr D's assumptions.
Kroll totally misrepresented what Dr. Demarais said and therefore he demonstrated his lack of knowledge rather than refuting Dr. D's work.
Also remember that Alt got this started but he has been gone for years. When he started this, he stated that changes would undoubtedly need to be made. This is no longer Alts plan. It stopped being Alts plan when he left
Now that's just plain silly . All of the principles of Alt's plan are still in effect and it doesn't matter what you call it. The fact remains the plan decreased breeding rates and productivity without decreasing the breeding window. Breeding rates and productivity also decreased at the Kinzua QDM area where the herd was reduced by 48%.
Obviously the experts were wrong and this armchair biologist was right, which proves you don't have to be an expert to understand the basics of deer management.