Like I said JD I don' t know how the Muleys in Canada react, might be a whole different ball a wax. But here in the western US doing rattlin would be like bringing an elk bugle on a turkey hunt. Everyone in the general vicinity, including the deer, might just have a chuckle at your expense. 1000' s of hunters with years of experience can' t be wrong. Point is no one does it cuz it just don' t work HERE. Again don' t know about Canada. Would you still make love to your lady the same way if she had a chuckle at your expense?