Could you please exlain that? What are your standard based on? Obviously not in field performance since this was the first deer you've ever shot. How can you say one broadhead is not a good one even though you've never shot a deer with one? Then, say another is great because you shot one doe? I think we all knew that a Rage would kill a deer, since we've all seen itcountless times on tv. This sure doesn't seem like a "review", just another opinion. Nothing wrong with that, but you don't seem to have much to baseit on. It's a safe bet Muzzy heads have killed more animals than Rage heads ever will, so they must be up to someone's standards. I'm just curious what your standards are based on.