Maybe so....but I can get my feet closer to the tree with it "up"....and in the "up" position....it sorta fits into my mid section, better.

Just try it. I was surprised. You can also use the little padded strap to secure the seat to it....and make it immobile. In the "down" position....it bumps my shins/thighs. "Up"....it's more out of the way. Like I said.....just try it. If it doesn't "work" for you.....just disregard!